The Best Italian Restaurant in South Valley Utah: Inside Toscano's Farm-to-Table Kitchen — And Why Draper Has Been Quietly Winning

The Kind of Restaurant You Drive Past Twice Before You Finally Go In

You've probably seen the building a hundred times — that sleek, modern exterior hugging State Street just off the I-15 interchange in Draper, floor-to-ceiling glass glowing amber in the early evening like a lantern someone left on for you. You've wondered. You've meant to go. And then you kept driving.

Stop driving.

Toscano has been the best Italian restaurant in South Valley Utah for years now, and the South Valley just hasn't gotten loud enough about it. Tucked at 11450 South State Street — technically Draper, practically the geographic heart of Salt Lake County's entire south half — this place is doing something that no competitor in the Sandy-Draper corridor has managed to replicate: a genuinely farm-to-table Italian kitchen operating inside one of the most striking dining rooms in the state, paired with a house-crafted spirits program, and somehow still managing to feel like the kind of place you'd go on a Tuesday.

"The food is always fresh, delicious, and made with so much care. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients in everything they make."

That's not a press release. That's a real diner describing what it actually feels like to eat here. And once you've sat in the Garden — under the retractable roof, next to the fountains, beside herbs the kitchen harvested that same morning — you'll understand exactly what they mean.

A Locally Sourced Italian Vision Planted in Draper's South Valley

Toscano began with a clear conviction: that the South Valley deserved a farm-to-table Italian dining experience that didn't require a drive into Salt Lake City proper. The kind of place where house-made pasta and locally sourced Utah proteins sit alongside signature Naples-style pizzas that have followed loyal diners through multiple iterations of the concept.

What distinguishes Toscano from every Italian restaurant in Sandy, South Jordan, and Draper isn't just the menu — it's the philosophy behind how the menu is built. Each day, the kitchen staff walks into The Garden and harvests from the full working herb garden planted there. Those same herbs end up in your pasta sauce that night. That's not marketing copy. That's the actual supply chain operating in real time, from soil to bowl, at a restaurant accessible directly off an interstate exit.

The menu balances Italian-American tradition with New American seasonal sensibility — a dual identity that gives the kitchen the freedom to honor classics like bolognese and carbonara while rotating in specials that take full advantage of what's fresh and locally sourced in Utah at any given moment. It's the kind of creative flexibility that keeps regulars coming back, because the menu they loved six months ago has evolved, but hasn't betrayed them.

The restaurant also developed its own house brand — Salt Flats Brewery and Salt Flats Spirits — creating a beverage program that is, quite literally, unreplicable anywhere else in the South Valley. The Bonneville Bourbon, the craft IPAs, the smoked old fashioned: these aren't just cocktail menu items, they're owned territory. When you're sipping a Salt Flats spirit at Toscano, you're having an experience that exists nowhere else in Utah dining.

Let's be clear about something: the carbonara alone is worth the trip from anywhere in Salt Lake County.

OpenTable diners have called it the "Best Carbonara we have ever had" — not the best in Draper, not the best in the South Valley, but the best they've personally encountered. That's a declaration worth unpacking. Classic carbonara is a technically unforgiving dish: eggs, Parmigiano Reggiano, pancetta, pasta water, no cream. Get the temperature wrong and you've got scrambled eggs on spaghetti. Toscano gets the temperature right, consistently, in a dining room that turns multiple covers a night.

"I highly recommend the Carbonara!!" wrote another OpenTable reviewer who came to celebrate a birthday and ended up ordering it on every return visit. When a dish becomes someone's reason to keep coming back, it's earned its place on the menu.

But don't let the carbonara crowd out everything else on the table. The house-made potato gnocchi is a standout — pillowy, substantial, served with your choice of marinara, alfredo, pesto, or bolognese with Parmigiano Reggiano and fresh basil. The gnocchi here is made in-house, which is rarer than it should be at any Italian restaurant in Utah, and you can taste the difference. The pasta is the actual topic, not just a vehicle for sauce.

For seafood, the crispy skin Idaho trout — served with butternut squash, zucchini, pancetta, and a garlic herb lemon vinaigrette — reflects exactly the kind of seasonal, locally sourced thinking that makes Toscano a farm-to-table Italian restaurant rather than just an Italian restaurant that says it is. The lamb shank risotto, a recurring special, consistently earns its own fanbase among returning diners. One reviewer described the kitchen's proteins as genuinely well-seasoned and tender — an observation that applied across the board.

The Naples-style pizzas are their own category of conversation. Reviewers have called them surprisingly authentic, comparing the experience to Italian-made pizza in a way that almost never happens in suburban Utah dining. You can even split a pizza between two preparations — a small personalization detail that somehow perfectly captures how Toscano thinks about its guests.

Then there's the chocolate gelato. The house-made gelato program is an extension of the same philosophy driving the whole menu — make it right, make it fresh, don't cut corners. Reviewers describe the chocolate gelato specifically for its intense flavors and delightful texture, and the cannoli alongside it has developed its own following. These aren't desserts that exist to fill a menu slot. They're the punctuation on a meal that was already doing a lot of heavy lifting.

The Garden, The Trees, and the Oquirrh Mountain View: Why the Room Is Half the Experience

Most restaurant dining rooms in the South Valley are fine. Toscano's is memorable.

The main dining room operates under a tall peaked ceiling that allows 20-foot live trees — full Ficus trees strung with soft lighting — to grow indoors year-round. The effect is something between a greenhouse and a luxury dining room: cozy despite the generous scale, romantic without being precious. Floor-to-ceiling window walls face both east and west, which means the evening light through those Oquirrh Mountain sunsets lands directly on your table. It's the kind of ambient detail that makes food taste better because your entire nervous system relaxes.

"The high ceiling allowed several full-size Ficus trees to thrive, each adorned with romantic strings of lights... billowing black drapery softened the ceiling's lines and helped create a cozy atmosphere despite the size of the dining room."

That's from a detailed dining review that noted the room's balance of grandeur and warmth — a balance that's genuinely hard to achieve in a space this size.

The Garden is Toscano's protected outdoor dining area with a closeable roof, meaning year-round outdoor dining in Utah, where that phrase usually doesn't apply. Fountains, music, plants, and that working herb garden make it a genuine outdoor environment, not a glorified parking lot with heaters. The Garden also converts for private events: rehearsal dinners, corporate celebrations, holiday parties. The private dining rooms throughout the restaurant mirror the main room's energy with the same elevated atmosphere and full-service bar access.

Farm-to-Table Italian in the Heart of South Valley Utah's Food Scene

Toscano holds an interesting position in Utah's dining landscape. It's not a downtown SLC restaurant with a built-in foodie audience already conditioned to pay attention. It's a South Valley restaurant serving Draper, Sandy, and South Jordan — communities whose residents have historically driven north for this caliber of Italian dining.

That's exactly what makes what Toscano is doing feel quietly significant. The daily herb harvest feeding a genuine farm-to-table Italian kitchen. The house distillery and brewery operating under the same roof. The commitment to locally sourced Utah proteins and seasonal vegetables that shows up in every rotating special. This is an ambitious food program operating in a zip code that most food writers still overlook.

The practical geography matters too: Toscano sits within easy reach of Hale Centre Theatre, the Living Planet Aquarium, the South Town Expo Center, and Sandy Amphitheater. Pre-show dinners, post-game celebrations, anniversary lunches — Toscano has quietly become the go-to occasion restaurant for anyone on the south end of the valley who doesn't want to compromise on quality.

"We dined with a party of four! And Toscano impressed us so much we booked a birthday party for 14!"

That's the pattern that keeps appearing in review after review: people show up skeptical, get genuinely surprised, and immediately start planning their return.

Planning Your Visit to Toscano

Address: 11450 S State St, Draper, UT 84020 — directly off I-15 at the 11400 South exit. Private parking lot, easy in and out.

Phone: (801) 572-5507

Hours: Monday–Friday 11:00 AM–9:00 PM (10:00 PM Fridays) · Saturday 4:00 PM–10:00 PM · Sunday 4:00 PM–9:00 PM

Reservations: Available via OpenTable. Strongly recommended for weekend evenings and parties of 6+. Private dining rooms available for events — call directly to book.

What to Order: Start with the bruschetta or baked brie. For pasta, the carbonara is non-negotiable, and the house-made potato gnocchi is the second-best thing on that section of the menu. For entrees, ask about current specials — the lamb shank risotto and seasonal seafood preparations are where the kitchen shows off. Finish with the chocolate gelato or the cannoli.

Drinks: Full bar featuring Salt Flats Brewery and Salt Flats Spirits house brands. BYO wine with corkage fee. The smoked old fashioned with Bonneville Bourbon is the signature move.

Best For: Date nights, anniversary dinners, pre-show meals before Hale Centre Theatre, birthday parties, business lunches, and family dinners. Gluten-free rotini pasta available as a sub on all pasta dishes.

The South Valley Has Been Sleeping on Something Great

There's a particular kind of restaurant that a city needs — the one that proves you don't have to drive to a trendier neighborhood to eat exceptionally well. Toscano is that restaurant for the south half of Salt Lake County. The farm-to-table Italian ambition, the house spirits program, the herb garden feeding the kitchen in real time, the room with the live trees and the sunset views — none of this is accidental. This is a considered, intentional dining experience that happens to exist minutes from the freeway.

"Incredible experience as always. We love Toscano."

That's what it looks like when a restaurant actually earns its regulars. Not through novelty, but through consistency — through a commitment to locally sourced ingredients and house-made everything that doesn't waver even when the dining room fills up and the Garden is buzzing on a Friday night.

If you've been thinking about going to Toscano, this is your sign. Make the reservation. Order the carbonara. Sit by the window and watch the Oquirrh Mountains turn gold.

The best Italian restaurant in South Valley Utah has been waiting for you.

📍 Toscano · 11450 S State St, Draper, UT 84020 · (801) 572-5507 · toscano-restaurant.com

Back to blog