There's a small historic building on Main Street in Pleasant Grove where something remarkable is happening. Walk through the door of Guayoyo Café on any given morning, and you'll find Numa Parra or one of his kids behind the counter, greeting every single person like they're family. "The empanadas world class!! The mushroom and goat cheese one is a MUST," raves one regular customer. This isn't just another coffee shop trying to differentiate itself with international flavors—this is a Venezuelan family sharing their entire world, one hand-crafted empanada and one pour-over coffee at a time, in what's become the only authentic Venezuelan restaurant in Salt Lake City.
The smell hits you first: warm corn masa baking, the bright notes of cilantro and chimichurri, specialty coffee from Colombia and Guatemala brewing in the background. It's a scent that tells a story about migration, resilience, and what happens when a family decides to recreate the cultural unity they left behind.
From Caracas to Pleasant Grove: The Journey Behind Salt Lake City's Venezuelan Food Scene
Numa Parra brought his family to the United States from Venezuela in 2014, first settling in Miami before making their way to Utah. The journey wasn't easy—leaving a country in crisis, rebuilding in a new place, learning to navigate a state where finding your community meant creating it yourself.
Parra's daughter Ana explained that when they first came from Venezuela, they lived in Miami for a few years and found a strong sense of "cultural unity" there. But when they moved to Utah, they found "there wasn't a place where people from all over the world could come in and feel like home." That realization became the blueprint for Guayoyo Café.
The name itself is a love letter to Venezuelan coffee culture. Guayoyo—pronounced "gwa-YO-yo"—refers to a traditional Venezuelan pour-over coffee, a method that's been used in Venezuelan homes since colonial times. It's typically a lighter, more approachable brew than espresso, meant to be sipped slowly with visitors. In Venezuela, offering someone a guayoyo is a gesture of hospitality, a way of saying "you're welcome here." That philosophy permeates every corner of this place.
With his son David Fuenmayor translating, Parra said he got the idea to open a coffee shop partly because he's a big fan of coffee. But it's clear this was about more than caffeine. Parra and his wife Emilia Garcia had started multiple businesses in Utah, and each one was another thread connecting them to their new home. Opening Guayoyo Café in summer 2024 was about building something permanent—a third place where Venezuelans could find familiar flavors, and where curious Utahns could discover an entire cuisine they'd probably never encountered.
What Makes Guayoyo Café Different: The Empanadas That Have Everyone Talking
Let's talk about these empanadas, because holy hell, they deserve their own paragraph. Most people think "empanada" and picture the fried, greasy pocket you get at a food truck. These are... not that. Inspired by Argentina, they brought in baked empanadas which are outstanding and come with some really great sauces. The dough is thin and crispy, almost pastry-like, with a satisfying crunch that gives way to generous fillings made from scratch daily.
The menu features several varieties, each with its own personality. La Tradicional stays true to classic South American flavors with premium ground beef, tri-color peppers, hard-boiled egg, and green olives—the kind of empanada that feels like someone's grandmother spent all morning perfecting it. "I have tried all of their empanadas from the Chicken, Traditional meat, Spinach and feta, the Pulled Pork Texas and have yet to be disappointed. They are the best I have had in Utah!!!" one customer wrote on Tripadvisor.
But the real star, the one that converts skeptics into evangelists, is La Exquisita—mushroom and goat cheese wrapped in that golden, flaky dough. "My favorite is the Exquisita that has mushroom and goat cheese," multiple reviewers mention. The earthiness of the mushrooms plays against the tang of goat cheese, and when you add their house-made smoked garlic sauce on top? It's the kind of bite that makes you understand why people drive from Salt Lake City to Pleasant Grove specifically for these.
La Jugosa brings shredded chicken cooked with bell peppers, onions, garlic, sweet peppers, and fresh cilantro. La Texana goes rogue with slow-cooked pulled pork and house-made BBQ sauce—a fusion that probably makes purists clutch their pearls but tastes incredible. There's also a spinach and feta option for vegetarians, and the fact that all these empanadas are baked rather than fried means they're surprisingly light. You can easily put away two or three without that food coma setting in.
The sauces deserve their own mention. That smoked garlic sauce customers keep raving about? It's got the depth of something that's been developing flavor for hours, with just enough kick to make each bite interesting. The chimichurri is bright with herbs, cutting through the richness of the fillings. These aren't afterthoughts—they're crafted to make each empanada even better.
Coffee Culture Meets Latin American Tradition: A Specialty Coffee Experience
While the empanadas might be what initially brings people in, the coffee program at Guayoyo Café is what keeps them coming back weekly. Their coffee comes from Colombia, Guatemala and Costa Rica, regions known for producing some of the world's most sought-after beans. But sourcing quality beans is only half the battle—it's what you do with them that matters.
The El Bombón, a sweet and robust coffee topped with vanilla cream, is their signature drink, a nod to Spanish coffee culture. It's made with equal parts condensed milk and coffee, creating this layered effect that's as visually stunning as it is delicious. The sweetness is intense but balanced, and that vanilla cream on top adds a luxurious texture. "It was the perfect combination of sweet and robust," even when customers ask for less condensed milk.
Then there's the Matcha Rosé, which sounds like it wandered in from a trendy Los Angeles café but somehow feels right at home here. It's "a visually stunning blend of matcha and rose," and watching them make it is part of the experience—layers of color, careful pours, artistic drizzles of syrup. "We came to try the coffee flight! Matcha was my favorite," one customer mentioned, highlighting how the coffee flight lets you sample multiple drinks in smaller portions alongside cookies.
For those who want something more traditional, the pistachio coffee has developed its own following. "The pistachio coffee a must!!" enthusiasts declare. And of course, they make the actual guayoyo—that traditional Venezuelan pour-over that gave the café its name. It's a lighter, cleaner brew that lets you taste the coffee itself without a lot of interference, the kind of cup that's meant for conversation rather than a caffeine jolt.
Whatever coffee drink you order will be gorgeous; all of the drinks at Guayoyo Café have tons of visual appeal, with dashes of cinnamon and drizzles of syrups and sauces making them perfect for Instagram. But here's the thing—they taste as good as they look, which isn't always the case with photogenic food and drinks.
Beyond Coffee and Empanadas: Exploring the Full Menu
While empanadas and coffee are the main attractions, Guayoyo Café has been quietly expanding their menu with other Latin American specialties. The picanha sandwich comes from Brazil, and it's a beast—El Conquistador features thin slices of tender picanha steak with truffle aioli, sriracha aioli, house-made chimichurri, Swiss cheese, arugula, and roasted red peppers. "This sandwich was so tasty: The meat was unbelievably tender and flavorful, and the combination of all the different components just really sang."
The genius here is how they've drawn inspiration from multiple Latin American countries without losing coherence. Ana Parra said they drew inspiration for their menu from a variety of countries, "where everybody could have something that they liked." It's not fusion for fusion's sake—it's a family sharing the diverse food traditions they encountered across their journey through the Americas.
Ana Parra also mentioned they plan to expand their menu soon with brunch offerings, which makes sense given the café's cozy morning atmosphere. The current menu is focused but not limited—there's enough variety that you could visit weekly and not get bored, but it's not so sprawling that quality suffers.
Everything is made to order, which means there's a brief wait, but watching the family work behind the counter is part of the charm. You can see them assembling sandwiches, pulling fresh empanadas from the oven, crafting drinks with genuine care. In an era of automated everything, there's something deeply satisfying about watching actual human hands make your food.
The Guayoyo Experience: Why This Place Feels Different
Walk into most coffee shops these days and you'll find a sterile minimalism—white walls, Edison bulbs, maybe a succulent if they're feeling wild. Guayoyo Café is the opposite of that. The interior is gorgeous, with a knickknack shelf full of colorful mugs, plus lots of windows, greenery and soft lighting.
The Pleasant Grove location sits in a charming historic building with outdoor seating out front, perfect for those rare Utah mornings when the temperature is just right. Inside, you'll find lovely little tables, photos on the walls, and that general sense that someone actually lives here. It feels like stepping into someone's home, which is precisely the point.
Fuenmayor said achieving a homey feel at the café was a main focus. "We try to get that familiar, warm welcome, so everybody will feel comfortable." And it works. Whether you're Venezuelan and craving a taste of home, or you're a curious local trying to expand your palate, you're getting the same genuine warmth.
The family presence is constant—you'll likely meet multiple generations of the Parra family during any given visit. Numa might be managing the kitchen, his son David helping with orders, his daughter Ana ensuring everything runs smoothly. This isn't some corporate operation where baristas clock in and out without investment. Every person behind that counter has skin in the game, literally.
Customers describe the café capturing "the essence of warmth and coziness, making it a delightful spot for coffee aficionados and food lovers alike." The service is consistently praised—people note how friendly and helpful the staff is, how they greet everyone with bright smiles, how they're patient explaining dishes to first-timers.
One small note: the historic building does present some accessibility challenges. There's a step at the front door which may pose challenges for wheelchair accessibility. It's worth mentioning if you're planning to visit with mobility concerns.
Utah's Growing Venezuelan Food Scene
Guayoyo Café's success speaks to something larger happening in Utah's food landscape. For years, "international food" in Utah meant Chinese, Mexican, maybe Thai if you were adventurous. But the state's changing demographics and increasingly curious food culture have created space for cuisines that were previously underrepresented.
Venezuelan food remains rare even in major American cities—most people's only exposure might be a Venezuelan restaurant in Miami or New York. Having an authentic Venezuelan restaurant in Salt Lake City (well, technically Pleasant Grove, but close enough) is legitimately special. It represents not just business opportunity but cultural preservation, a way for Venezuelan families to maintain their traditions while sharing them with a new community.
The café opened a second location in June 2025 at 7173 S. Redwood Road in West Jordan, next to Jurassic Tacos. The expansion suggests they've found their audience—people hungry for something different, for flavors that tell stories, for places where hospitality isn't just a business strategy but a cultural imperative.
Planning Your Visit to Guayoyo Café
Pleasant Grove Location: 19 S Main St, Pleasant Grove, UT 84062 Monday-Saturday: 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM Sunday: 8:00 AM - 2:00 PM
West Jordan Location: 7173 S Redwood Rd, Suite 101, West Jordan, UT 84084 Monday-Saturday: 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM Sunday: 8:00 AM - 2:00 PM
What to Order: Start with La Exquisita empanada (mushroom and goat cheese) and La Tradicional (the classic beef). Don't skip the smoked garlic sauce. For drinks, get the El Bombón coffee if you like sweet and robust, or try the coffee flight if you want to sample several options. If you're hungry, the El Conquistador sandwich is legitimately impressive.
Insider Tips:
Parking is free street parking along Main Street in Pleasant Grove
The café takes orders via tablet at the table, making the process straightforward
Everything is made to order, so factor in a 10-15 minute wait during busy times
They offer various milk options for coffee drinks
Perfect for catching up with friends or working remotely—the atmosphere encourages lingering
Find Them Online: Instagram: @guayoyocafeutah Website: guayoyocafe.com Phone: (801) 301-5596
Why Guayoyo Café Matters to Utah's Food Story
In a state still finding its culinary identity beyond fry sauce and funeral potatoes, places like Guayoyo Café are essential. They expand our collective palate, sure, but more importantly, they remind us what hospitality actually means. Parra and his family wanted to create a place "where people from all over the world could come in and feel like home," and in doing so, they've created something that feels like home to Utahns who've never been anywhere near Venezuela.
The food is legitimately excellent—those empanadas earn every rave review, the coffee program is thoughtful and well-executed, and the expanding menu shows ambition beyond being a one-trick pony. But what elevates Guayoyo Café from good to essential is that ineffable quality of genuine warmth, the sense that you're not just a customer but a guest in someone's home.
"Utah is a better place with Guayoyo!!" one customer wrote, and honestly? They're not wrong. Every city needs places like this—places that take the risk of sharing something unfamiliar, places run by families who see food as a bridge rather than just a business, places where "Venezuelan restaurant Salt Lake City" stops being a Google search query and becomes an actual destination worth the drive.
Whether you're Venezuelan and homesick for real empanadas, a coffee nerd always hunting the next great cup, or just someone tired of the same rotation of chain restaurants, Guayoyo Café delivers something rare: authenticity without pretension, quality without compromise, and hospitality that feels less like service and more like family.