Murphy's Cafe 126: Where Riverton Found Utah's Best Philly Cheesesteak

Walk into Murphy's Cafe 126 on a Friday afternoon and you'll find Daniel Murphy behind the counter, greeting customers like old friends, checking that every sandwich leaving his kitchen meets his exacting standards. The chandeliers overhead catch the light just right, the smell of perfectly seasoned steak hits you before you even reach the register, and somewhere in the background, someone's probably asking for extra jalapeño fry sauce. Because that's what happens here—people find something they love and they can't help coming back for it.

One customer put it this way: "The owner taking time to visit and share was out of this world. I was so impressed with the experience. This has moved to the top of my list of places I like to visit."

This is the kind of place where a former mortgage broker decided to bet everything on making the best Philly cheesesteak in Utah. And judging by the lines at lunch and the 1,143 Google reviews, he might've actually pulled it off.

From Mortgage Desks to Griddles: Daniel Murphy's Pivot

Daniel Murphy didn't wake up one day and decide to open a restaurant on a whim. He'd been cooking on the side for years while working as a mortgage broker, feeding friends and family, perfecting his technique. But there's a difference between cooking for people you love and opening your doors to the public on April 13, 2019.

"The most exciting thing is watching the customers face when they eat the food," Murphy told Fox 13 in 2021. That right there tells you everything about why this place exists—not for Instagram glory or expansion dreams (though he had those at first), but for that moment when someone bites into a sandwich that exceeds their expectations.

Murphy's approach to cheesesteaks isn't complicated, but it is meticulous. He studied what made authentic Philly cheesesteaks work, sourced high-quality ingredients, and refused to cut corners even when food costs skyrocketed during the pandemic. When 40 pounds of wings jumped from $107 to $146, he didn't switch suppliers or shrink portions—he adjusted and kept going.

A self-described cheesesteak snob from out of state confirmed what locals already knew: "Daniel, the owner has done his homework to put together an authentic Philly cheesesteak! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND!"

Located at 12575 S Rhetski Ln in Riverton, just off 12600 South and Bangerter, Murphy's has become the kind of neighborhood spot where the owner works alongside his staff, where customers try to leave cash tips even when told it's not necessary, and where regulars plan what they're ordering next time before they've finished their current sandwich.

The Cheesesteak Experience: What Makes Murphy's Different

Here's what you need to understand about Murphy's cheesesteaks—they're not trying to reinvent anything. They're trying to perfect something. Thinly sliced steak (or pulled chicken if that's your preference), sautéed mushrooms, red and green bell peppers, onions, provolone cheese, and that crucial seasoned mayo. Get the basics right, then offer variations that make sense.

The Mushroom Pepper Cheesesteak is Murphy's personal favorite, the one he named after himself. Peppered steak or chicken, loads of sautéed mushrooms, tender bell peppers and onions, provolone, seasoned mayo, finished with cracked black pepper. One couple split the 10-inch version and couldn't stop talking about it: "Meat was tender, veggies were delicious, sauce added just enough flavor, and the bread was soft and fresh with just the right amount of crisp on the outside."

The Original Philly keeps it traditional, and customers who've been eating cheesesteaks their entire lives confirm it passes the test. As one reviewer noted, "Got the original Philly and it was the best one I've had in years!"

Then there's the creative territory—the Jalapeño Cheesesteak with fresh grilled jalapeños (not pickled), the Honey Garlic that one birthday dinner guest called "absolutely delightful," the BBQ Cheesesteak, and even a Whiz Cheesesteak for purists who insist on Cheez Whiz.

A food critic's husband, notoriously hard to impress, ordered the Mushroom Pepper with added jalapeños and his wife reported: "It's what a REAL Philly Cheesesteak looks and tastes like. There were large cracked black pepper that made it warm (spicy-wise), but not overwhelming. And the cheese was ooey-gooey."

But here's the thing about Murphy's—the vegetables are fresh and high-quality, a choice that costs more but makes a difference you can taste. The meat is properly seasoned without being oversalted. The bread has that perfect ratio of soft interior to crispy exterior. And every sandwich is made fresh to order, which means you might wait a few extra minutes during the lunch rush, but you're never getting something that's been sitting under a heat lamp.

One Baltimore transplant, someone who actually knows what authentic East Coast cheesesteaks should taste like, had this to say: "I'm from Baltimore City and I moved out here to SLC 8 years ago and I know what a good Philly Steak taste like! This place is truly that good."

The Secret Weapon: Fries and That Jalapeño Sauce

If you order just a cheesesteak at Murphy's, you're doing it wrong. The fries here have developed their own following—crispy, airy, not overly potato-heavy. One customer described them as "incredible. They were crispy and kinda airy, not a ton of potato in it."

The Sweet Potato Fries get consistently praised for being "out of this world" and arriving "fresh, hot and crispy." The Onion Rings maintain their crunch even through delivery. And the Bacon Cheese Fries? Those alone are worth the trip. Real bacon, actual cheese (not the fake stuff), perfectly crispy fries.

But the real game-changer is the jalapeño fry sauce. If you've never had it, you need to understand—this isn't just fry sauce with some heat added. It's balanced, it's got kick without overwhelming, and it elevates every single side dish it touches. Multiple reviews mention it specifically, with one customer noting it "took the fries to the next level!"

As another regular put it: "Don't forget to ask for the jalapeño fry sauce. Yum. We will be returning for sure."

The Tater Tots are another favorite, and you can even get your cheesesteak served on tots instead of bread if you're feeling adventurous. It's the kind of menu flexibility that shows Murphy understands his customers aren't all looking for the same experience.

While cheesesteaks built Murphy's reputation, the menu has expanded in ways that make sense for a family-friendly Riverton cafe. The burgers use fresh Angus beef and come with creative variations—the Blue Cheese Burger with bacon and blue cheese dressing, the Honey Garlic Burger, the Jalapeño Bacon Burger with fresh grilled jalapeños.

One mushroom burger fan couldn't finish it but "enjoyed every bite" and noted it was "BIG, juicy and delicious."

The chicken tacos surprise people who come specifically for cheesesteaks. Multiple reviews mention them as standouts, and one person noted they were ordering them again on their next visit.

There's also a breakfast menu that regulars swear by. One three-year customer wrote: "Breakfast is amazing too. Their cook is always on point and of the last 3 years we've been coming here I have never once had a bad meal."

The Garlic Parmesan Wings and Cream Cheese Steak have their devoted fans. And for those watching their carb intake, Murphy's offers a "no bread" option—a 6-inch Philly cheesesteak without the bread, served with fries, lots of cheese, peppers, and mushrooms.

The Murphy's Cafe Experience: Why People Keep Coming Back

There's a moment that keeps happening at Murphy's, and it tells you everything about what this place has become. Customers try to leave cash tips. The staff says no, that's not necessary. The customers insist. As one reviewer wrote: "We're ashamed that we didn't tip when we ordered, and we tried giving them cash. They refused, saying we didn't need to. We were unsuccessful in leaving a cash tip, but be warned! Next time we come back, ya'll are getting a HUGE tip when we pay!!"

That exchange doesn't happen at corporate restaurants. It happens at places where the owner is working the line during lunch rush, where the staff is genuinely enthusiastic about the food they're serving, where you're greeted at the door like you matter.

Murphy navigated through pandemic labor shortages by installing self-order kiosks (found on YouTube during a particularly desperate search for solutions), hired high school students from nearby Riverton High School, and posted honest updates on Facebook about longer wait times and the occasional wrong order. He didn't pretend everything was perfect—he was transparent about the challenges while refusing to give up.

"I am not one to give up," Murphy wrote during the height of pandemic difficulties. "I did not start Murphy's to end it just because things get difficult. We will adjust."

The atmosphere reflects that practical, unpretentious approach. The dining area is clean with those surprisingly elegant chandeliers, maybe 6-7 four-seat tables, a soda station, and an impressive coffee bar with espresso and latte options. It's the kind of space that works for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a birthday celebration.

One couple familiar with running restaurants themselves said they were "honestly stingy when it comes to tipping and extremely picky when it comes to eating out," but at Murphy's they were "IMPRESSED" (their capitals, not mine). The owner explained the menu enthusiastically, food arrived within minutes, everything was hot and fresh, and when they mentioned a birthday, the staff immediately looked for ways to make it special.

Another customer captured the vibe perfectly: "Mom and pop shop filled to the brim with class and good service. The owner was working the front and treating his customers like family."

Planning Your Visit to Murphy's Cafe 126

Location & Hours:
12575 S Rhetski Ln, Unit 103
Riverton, UT 84065
(Just off 12600 South and Bangerter, across from Riverton Hospital)

Current Hours:
Monday-Wednesday: 11 AM - 3 PM
Thursday: 11 AM - 8 PM
Friday-Saturday: 11 AM - 9 PM
Sunday: 12 PM - 7 PM

(Note: Hours have adjusted over time due to staffing, so it's worth checking their website or calling ahead: (801) 367-6162)

What to Order:
First-timers should get the Mushroom Pepper Cheesesteak (it's the owner's favorite for a reason) or the Original Philly if you want traditional. Add the Bacon Cheese Fries or Sweet Potato Fries with jalapeño fry sauce—this is non-negotiable. If you're particularly hungry or feeding a family, the burgers and chicken tacos are legit options, not menu fillers.

Insider Tips:

Peak lunch hours can get busy, especially Thursday-Saturday
They offer delivery through DoorDash and online ordering through their website
No phone orders currently accepted due to limited staff
Kid-sized meals available and generously portioned
Student specials offered (makes sense with Riverton High School nearby)
Parking available on-site
Family-friendly atmosphere, wheelchair accessible

Pricing:
Cheesesteaks run around $10-15 depending on size and toppings. It's not the cheapest lunch in Riverton, but portions are generous and ingredients are high-quality. One reviewer noted a large cheesesteak and fries came to over $25, which is steep, but most customers feel the quality justifies the cost.

Instagram: @murphyscafe126
(Follow for daily specials and menu updates)

Murphy's also has a second location downtown Salt Lake City at 23 N 900th W if you're in that area, though the Riverton location is the original.

The Bottom Line: Utah's Cheesesteak Destination

Here's the reality—Riverton isn't exactly known as a culinary destination. It's suburbs, strip malls, families, people commuting to jobs in Salt Lake City. But that's exactly why Murphy's Cafe 126 matters. Daniel Murphy could've played it safe, kept his mortgage broker job, cooked for friends on weekends. Instead, he took a risk on a simple premise: make really good cheesesteaks with quality ingredients, treat customers like family, and don't cut corners even when it gets hard.

The result is a place where a Baltimore native confirms the cheesesteaks are authentic, where cheesesteak snobs admit they're impressed, where families celebrate birthdays, where regulars are already planning their next order before they finish their current sandwich.

One customer summed it up this way: "You walk in and feel like you're already part of the family. He's always got a smile, always checking that your order is right, and you can tell—this man takes pride in every single sandwich that leaves that kitchen."

That's not marketing language. That's what actually happens when you visit Murphy's Cafe 126—you get a damn good cheesesteak from someone who cares whether you enjoy it. In 2026, with everything corporatized and optimized and focus-grouped to death, that alone is worth the drive to Riverton.

Back to blog