The Best Gluten-Free Mexican Restaurant in Salt Lake City: How Grief Built Utah's Most Revolutionary Taco Spot at Contento Cafe

The chips arrive at your table piping hot, fried to golden perfection in grass-fed beef tallow—not the industrial seed oils most restaurants hide behind. You're sitting in what used to be Vertical Diner's space on West Temple in South Salt Lake, but everything feels different now. Warmer. More purposeful. One diner put it simply: "It's not often a Celiac gets to eat a freshly fried churro!" That's the thing about Contento Cafe—Utah's only 100% gluten-free Mexican restaurant isn't just accommodating celiacs and gluten-intolerant diners. It's reimagining what clean-eating Mexican food can be in a state that's finally waking up to the seed oil conversation.

Owner Loren Bell never imagined that the worst moment of his life would become the foundation for one of Salt Lake City's most groundbreaking restaurants. After moving to Utah from San Francisco in 1990 to study biology at the University of Utah, Loren transitioned into a full-time career as an arborist and master gardener. But in 2020, just a month after taking over the former Vertical Diner space, his wife took her own life after battling postpartum depression. "I disappeared for two years," Loren said softly. "I was raising two kids on my own. My son developed asthma - grief can do that to a little one."

The unfinished café sat dormant through the pandemic, through his grief, through the impossible days of single fatherhood. But as Loren explained, "I felt driven to finish what I started. It was important for them and for me." On Cinco de Mayo 2023, he finally opened the doors to Contento—Spanish for "happy"—and in doing so, created something Utah's food scene had been missing.

From Diet for a New America to Utah's Cleanest Mexican Kitchen

The seeds of Contento were planted decades before the restaurant opened. "I read Diet for a New America by John Robbins back in high school," Loren recalled. "It changed my life." The book, written by the heir to the Baskin-Robbins empire who walked away from the family fortune to advocate for ethical eating, challenged everything Loren thought he knew about food, farming, and health.

Fast forward thirty years, and those principles became the foundation of every dish Contento serves. "Everything we serve is organic and seed-oil free," Loren said. "Even the animal products - if they're not raised naturally, I won't touch them." This isn't marketing speak—it's a commitment you can taste. The grass-fed steak is sourced from cattle that graze on actual grass their entire lives. The salmon and shrimp are wild-caught, never farmed. Even Mary's Organic Chicken gets top billing on the menu because Loren knows where it comes from and how it was raised.

What makes Contento revolutionary in Salt Lake City's Mexican food landscape isn't just the ingredient quality—it's the dedicated gluten-free kitchen. There's no risk of cross-contamination here because there's literally no gluten in the building. As one celiac diner noted, "Food was delicious and it was comforting to know that the restaurant was dedicated GF." For the celiac community, this is borderline miraculous. Most Mexican restaurants offer a few gluten-free options; Contento built its entire operation around them.

And then there's the seed oil issue. Loren added a full bar and craft cocktails, explaining: "It's what people want when they're having Mexican food, and most places here only serve beer and wine." But he draws the line at cooking oils. While most restaurants fry everything in cheap canola or vegetable oil loaded with inflammatory omega-6 fatty acids, Contento uses only avocado oil and beef tallow. One customer who drives out of their way to support seed oil-free restaurants wrote: "Some of the best steak tacos I've ever had. Thank you for making your chips with beef tallow!!!"

The Contento Bowl and Wild-Caught Salmon That Changed Everything

Let's talk about what actually lands on your plate at this gluten-free Mexican restaurant in Salt Lake City. The Contento Bowl has become something of a cult favorite—so much so that Salt Lake Magazine's food writer admitted to ordering it three times before writing her review. The rainbow base consists of rice, black beans, house-made queso fresco and sour cream, pico de gallo, pickled red onion and esquites in a roasted jalapeño aioli.

But here's where Contento gets interesting. The Spanish rice actually has flavor to it rather than just some red color from tomato paste, and the beans are blow-the-skin-off tender—a quality only attainable when freshly made. When you add the wild-caught salmon with roasted pineapple, something magical happens. The caramelized pineapple chunks, cut to pico de gallo size, create sweet contrasts against the savory base. And that esquites? The toasty corn is held together in a creamy-smoky-spicy aioli with onion and cilantro.

The salmon tacos deserve their own paragraph. One reviewer described them as "summer dining Valhalla," noting that Contento's signature blend of shredded cabbage, pineapple and avocado brings the dish into a category of its own. For a state where fish tacos are often an afterthought, Contento's wild-caught approach feels revelatory.

Then there's breakfast, which runs from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. daily—because who decided breakfast food needs to stop at 11 a.m.? The chilaquiles might be the move here. Made with tallow-fried chips, eggs cooked your way, avocado, beans, rice, and sour cream, with the option of adding grass-fed steak, they hit the spot. As one breakfast enthusiast put it after trying the chilaquiles: "Oh wow, this place has good Mexican brunch and is really delicious."

But perhaps the most enthusiastic review came from a gluten-free diner who raved: "The horchata latte was so good, breakfast burrito was the best I've had since going gluten free, and the churros? Amazing." The fact that a celiac can order churros without hesitation speaks volumes.

The steak tacos also get consistent love. Axios described them as "expensive ($8.50 each), but they are large and delightful. The steak was tender and flavorful and paired well with the lightly crisp tortilla and pickled onions." That price point reflects the grass-fed, finished beef—not the feedlot stuff most taco shops use.

South Salt Lake's Answer to the Celiac Crisis

Here's what Contento represents for Salt Lake City's gluten-intolerant and celiac community: freedom. One diner captured it perfectly: "This was some of the best Mexican food I've had in Utah. 100% dedicated GF kitchen which was really nice." Another added that they felt safe enough to order anything from the menu—a luxury celiacs rarely experience.

The restaurant has become something of a pilgrimage site for gluten-free diners across the Wasatch Front. Loren noted that "People drive here from Draper, Bountiful, even Utah County." That's a 45-minute drive for some folks, but when you're dealing with celiac disease, finding a completely safe restaurant is worth the journey.

The consensus among celiac diners is clear: "We love this place, especially since it's 100% gluten free dedicated kitchen. The tacos are really great, including the breakfast tacos." The volume of positive reviews on Find Me Gluten Free—a platform specifically for celiacs—tells you everything you need to know about Contento's commitment to safety.

But Contento isn't just serving the celiac community. Loren explained his broader philosophy: "I'm not celiac. But I eat this way because I vote with my money. I don't support how they're growing our grains. I think if more people knew what was going into their food, they'd change how they eat too."

That authenticity resonates. One family reviewer noted: "It was so fun to try 'clean' Mexican food without any seed oils. I was so impressed by the food and the service." This is food people feel good about eating—not just because it's safe, but because it aligns with their values.

Coffee Snobs, Craft Cocktails, and the Full Contento Experience

Most Mexican restaurants in Utah stick to beer and wine. Loren went a different direction. "I'm snobby about coffee. It had to be done right," he said, adding that though he doesn't drink alcohol himself, he built a full bar with craft cocktails because "most places here only serve beer and wine."

The coffee program features espresso drinks and pour-overs made with single-origin beans. The horchata latte has become a signature—imagine traditional horchata's cinnamon-rice sweetness meeting espresso. It's so good that one customer simply called it "the best I've had since going gluten free." There's also a Mexican Mocha for those who want their chocolate fix with their morning caffeine.

On the cocktail side, the Batanga—a highball made with tequila and Mexican Coke—offers the kind of simple perfection that's harder to execute than it sounds. The Spicy Margarita consistently gets mentioned in reviews, and there's even a Rumchata situation happening that blends vodka, horchata, and espresso into something dangerously drinkable.

The vibe inside reflects the former Vertical Diner space but with Loren's personal touch. Axios noted that "the warm and cozy interior reminded me of Bar Flores, one of my favorite Los Angeles watering holes." The peach and white color scheme creates that southwestern feeling without veering into Tex-Mex cliché territory.

What Utah's Food Scene Didn't Know It Needed

Loren still works as a gardener and arborist, explaining: "I still care deeply about the environment. But here, I get to share something immediate with people. I get to nourish them." That dual commitment—to the land and to feeding people well—runs through everything at Contento.

The restaurant occupies an interesting position in South Salt Lake's evolving food landscape. It's taken over the space that once housed Vertical Diner, one of Utah's plant-based dining pioneers. As one reviewer noted, "It's fitting that their current digs used to belong to our friends at Vertical Diner." Both restaurants share a commitment to thoughtful ingredient sourcing, just from different philosophical angles.

What Contento proves is that you can serve traditional Mexican flavors—chilaquiles, birria, carnitas, fajitas—without compromising on ingredient quality or dietary safety. The gluten-free Mexican restaurant category barely existed in Salt Lake City before Contento. Now it's setting a standard that other restaurants will struggle to match.

Loren's vision is modest but powerful: "I never worked in a restaurant before this. But I always wanted to own one. And now, here it is. People come in, they feel good, and they come back."

Planning Your Visit to Contento Cafe

Contento Cafe sits at 2280 South West Temple in South Salt Lake, just south of downtown and easily accessible from I-15. Parking can be tight—there's a small lot behind the restaurant, but street parking works in a pinch.

Hours are Tuesday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., Friday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Saturday 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Sunday 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. They're closed Mondays. If you're coming for breakfast or brunch, know that the breakfast menu runs until 5 p.m. daily, so you've got flexibility.

What to order? Multiple reviewers mentioned the Contento Bowl as a must-try, with one noting: "The Contero Bowl was a real winner." If you're a taco person, the grass-fed steak tacos and wild-caught salmon tacos both get consistent love. For breakfast, regulars recommend the chilaquiles and breakfast tacos. And yes, get the chips and guac—those tallow-fried chips are worth it.

Don't skip dessert. As one enthusiastic reviewer put it: "We had the churros for dessert. I will dream about them until I go back." Recently, they've added rice pudding empanadas with house-made caramel ice cream, which sounds like the kind of thing you drive across town for.

Reservations are available through OpenTable, which is smart if you're coming on a Friday or Saturday night. The space isn't huge, and word has spread fast about this being Salt Lake City's only dedicated gluten-free Mexican restaurant.

Follow them on Instagram @contentocafeslc for menu updates, Taco Tuesday specials, and the occasional behind-the-scenes look at how they're sourcing ingredients.

---

In a city where Mexican food options run from fast-casual chains to upscale modern interpretations, Contento Cafe carved out something entirely its own. It's the only place in Utah where celiacs can order churros without asking seventeen questions. It's where seed oil-conscious eaters can get grass-fed steak tacos fried in beef tallow. It's where Loren Bell turned grief into something nourishing—not just for himself, but for a community of diners who've been waiting for exactly this kind of restaurant.

One reviewer captured the excitement: "First off I'll start by saying!! Enjoy this place while you can because I personally believe this place is going to BLOW UP!" They're probably right. Because Contento isn't just filling a gap in Salt Lake City's gluten-free dining scene—it's proving that Mexican food can be both traditionally delicious and radically clean at the same time.